Enhancing Learning in the Biology Laboratory
Dr. Thomas R. Lord
Burlington County College, Pemberton, New Jersey
Subject: Science/Biology
Grade: Higher Education
"Overall, any educational activity that would require the
student to recollect his or her involvement in the proceedings
would be enhanced by the use of sequential filming."
Purpose and Description of Project
Thomas Lord conducted an element with 98 General Biology II students
to see if learning in the biology laboratory could be enhanced
by photography. In particular, he wanted to ensure that students
were both physically and mentally involved in performing experiments.
Lord set three major objectives for his project: to determine
if the use of sequential still photos taken by students during
their weekly lab exercises would facilitate learning, to find
out if using instructor-taken still photos of the lab work in
a review session would enhance student learning, and to find out
if the use of sequential still photos of the lab experiments would
enhance the students' capacity to form mental images of the outside
events.
Lord divided his students into four equal groups:
- the control group, which followed the traditional scheme
of two lectures, one laboratory, and one seminar per week;
- the placebo group, which received a 20- to 30-minute verbal
presentation on the historical significance of each experiment
before the weekly lab session;
- the photo-record experimental
group, which recorded with black-and-white still photos the sequences
of events and outcomes during each lab;
- the photo-review
experimental group, which was given a pictorial review of
the lab activities at the end of each session with the help of
instructor-taken photos.
Activities
All groups of students performed identical experiments during
their two-hour lab sessions. Immediately following the lab sessions
of the photo record experimental group, the
film
was processed
by the college's Photography Department and returned to the lab
groups. Students who took photos of their lab work were encouraged
to use the photos in as many study modes as possible-e.g., preparing
for the seminars, writing lab reports, and reviewing for tests.
Materials, Resources, and Expenses
The laboratory materials and equipment utilized would be generally
found in any secondary- or college-level biology lab. The college
provided two
cameras
for student use, but most lab groups
recorded their work with their own cameras. All students used
KODAK TRI-X Film - at least one package per lab
group per session and more if necessary. The film was developed
and printed by personnel in the school's Photography Department.
Outcomes and Adaptability
Lord analyzed the outcomes of his project using three types of
evaluative measures: (1) Students were tested at the beginning
and end of the 15-week semester on their image formation and control
potentials. The pre-test showed little difference among the groups.
The post-test indicated that the two experimental groups had developed
a greater aptitude for handling spatial imagery tasks. (2) Three
practical lab exams were given during the semester; all question
areas-pertaining to macro- and microscopic examination of tissues,
organs, and organisms; graph and chart interpretation; and understanding
of chemical or physiological events-had been examined during the
lab sessions. Statistical examination of the exam scores showed
higher achievement. (3) In terms of semester grades, the experimental
groups scored significantly better on the lab segment of the course.
Observation indicated that the students in the photo-record experimental
group took extra care and pride in their work, and their extra
precision and interest resulted in greater achievement. Lord concludes
that the use of sequential photos does, indeed, enhance student
learning and possibly facilitates the translation of external
events into mental pictorial images.
Lord suggests that the incorporation of photography into the biology
lab would be relatively simple if student or school cameras and
the slide projector and screen were available. He finds that photography
could be used in a similar way in chemistry, physics, and earth
science labs.