Classification of Films for Storage
Classification of Films for Storage
When you consider the need for film storage of any kind, you must classify the film for its potential future use by its value as a record and by the length of time that it should be stored. Then find the best answer within your own resources.
For most of you, longer-range storage and preservation will probably not be an issue. You will probably use today's films today, and keep yesterday's films around only between frequent or fairly frequent screenings. You will have to make decisions.
Here is a checklist you can use as a guide:
Actually, only safety film (triacetate or polyester base), which carries silver images, can be used for extended life expectancy records-500 years for polyester base and 100 years for acetate. In some cases, there may be a combination of nitrate and acetate base films, with either silver or dye images, that have great historical value. You may need to preserve these different films even though you can't afford the expense to go through the separation method. The first thing that must be done is to segregate acetate and nitrate films for storage, because the two film bases do not mix, and nitrate is not suitable for any permanent storage record. Acetate base films can be chemically attacked by the gases given off by the decomposing, unstable nitrate-base films. There is no need to segregate black and-white and color films that have the same type of base.
We've discussed some of the hazards and problems of maintaining these products over short- and long-term periods under various conditions. Film is very much a match for paper, probably the oldest vehicle used for records and expressive arts. Modern safety film is more resistant to fire than paper. Let's now explore storage factors other than just temperature and relative humidity.
Commercial Storage of Acetate Film
Note: Films destined for projection should be wound emulsion-in, as specified in SMPTE Recommended Practice RP-39.
Educational-film users (very often do-it-yourselfers) need to carefully consider special situations. Generally, most of us are concerned with only short-term storage of films that travel a lot and often through somewhat lecithin-careful hands. Many films are destroyed because they're improperly handled. Your films can lose their educational value before being faced with the question of how to keep them around longer. Nevertheless, it's important to keep them clean and in good condition.
Storage facilities can be fairly simple rooms or closets maintained at about 24°C (75°F) or lower. If the room temperature is regularly at about 75°F, you will need air-conditioning to cool the room and a humidifier or dehumidifier to control the relative humidity at a range of 20 to 60 percent. It's best to have the RH between 20 and 30 percent so you can humidify or dehumidify accordingly. Lower temperatures are always preferable, so be sure to allow enough warm-up time when moving unprotected film to a warmer environment. Keep films out of direct sunlight, even if they are in cans. Sun-struck cans can get very hot inside, even when the room temperature is normal. Vertical storage of film cans (for short-term storage of films that are shipped a lot) allows more air circulation and easy access. For longer storage periods, you should utilize horizontal storage to reduce potential film-distortion problems.
Safe film storage is no better than the reels and containers that are used. Containers must be clean inside and out, and the reels must be in good condition. Bent, chipped, nicked, scratched, or broken reels almost always damage film. To avoid confusion and prevent unnecessary handling, clearly and prominently label the films. Ship films in adequate containers. The purpose of any container is to protect the goods inside, so take extra care to package film for shipping and storing.
Motion picture film on safety base can be stored safely in any suitable room for a reasonable period. The film, itself, doesn't constitute any more of a fire hazard than an open stack of bound books. So, sprinklers may not be necessary unless required by law.
If the acetate safety film doesn't enjoy the comforts of air conditioning, store it on one of the main floors of the building. Basements are too damp and top floors can be too hot in certain seasons. Get a room away from southern exposures. Use a room protected from accidental water damage from rain, water pipes, sewers, or floods.
Once you locate the ideal storage room, get suitable shelves or steel cabinets. Keep the lowest shelf at least six inches above the floor just in case of water, and keep the shelves and cabinets away from steam pipes, radiators, hot air ducts, and other heat producing sources. For long term storage, stack the films horizontally, rather than on edge, to minimize physical distortion. But don't stack them more than six or eight cans high because they're heavy and the bottom ones will be difficult to remove.
For film storage, the main thing is to stay away from attics and basements, and to maintain a room that offers a dean, cool, stable environment. Ideally, storage should be separated from work and traffic areas, especially if the collection has a large number (5,000 or more) of prints.
Minimal equipment includes a thermometer and humidity meter. Bare floors are best, no carpets. If possible, install tile floors because tile is easy to clean, and using it lessens the chance of static generation and its attraction of dust to the film. Concrete, if not treated, will create harmful dust. There should never be food, drink, or smoking in the storage area.
Storage Relative Humidity
Those in arid climates need to be sure that their storage areas are not consistently under 15 percent relative humidity or else film will become brittle. A humidifying unit may be needed. Suitable units are available from manufacturers around the world. Be sure that the controlling humidistat is set no higher than about 50 percent to prevent overhumidification.
Camera originals or intermediates in short term that may be used for printing should be stored at the RH of the printing rooms. This room to room equilibrium prevents film size change, which helps to keep the registration accurate while printing.
High relative humidity and temperature, over an extended period, can destroy a film. Low temperatures and humidities can help to preserve films, unless the relative humidity has been below 15 percent for an extended period.
Recommended Medium Term* Storage Condition for Processed Motion Picture Film
* A minimum of 10 years; as defined in IS0 2803 or ANSI PH1 43-1985, Practice for storage of processed safety photographic film. + Storage at less than 20°C (68°F) is preferable. ++For normal short term commercial storage, 21°C (70°F) at 40 to 50 percent RH is adequate. ** RH of 60 percent should not be exceeded for a medium term environment.
Storage in the Tropics
The following useful methods of preserving acetate safety film are arranged in order of decreasing cost and convenience; the "top of the line," comes first.
Automatic Air Conditioner
Such a system will not cool the room. Remember, also, that people working in the room, who may be inspecting or repairing film, need fresh air. Don't confuse dehumidifying units with window air conditioners. The latter do take some moisture out of the air due to condensation on the cooling coils, but they don't control relative humidity. If no moisture is removed from the air, cooling results in an increase in relative humidity. (This is why basements are usually damp.) If climate is humid, a dehumidifier is necessary. A local heating and air conditioning supplier can suggest the right equipment for these needs.
Desiccation with Silica Gel
One of the reasons why we emphasize the sorting of film types and segregating nitrate base films from any safety films, is that decomposing nitrate films give off nitrogen dioxide fumes which damage all three components of acetate and polyester base films the developed image, the gelatin, and the base.
1. Keep the roll of film wet. If the film dries, the convolutions may be stuck together, ruining the film. For holding wet or muddy films prior to the cleaning operation, immerse the roll completely in containers of cold water, below 18°C (65°F). The cold water will help prevent both swelling and softening of the emulsion, which are the major causes of damage.
2. With the roll completely submerged underwater, gently rub the edges of the film to remove most of the mud and silt. Make frequent water changes.
3. Unwind the wet film carefully and slowly. Pass the strand of film under running water to remove any remaining mud or silt. In extreme cases, a gentle scrubbing action with a cotton swab may be needed to remove stubborn particles. Be careful in swabbing the film because the wet emulsion is very susceptible to physical damage. From the running water, pass the film through a tank containing water and a laundry or dishwater type of water softening solution to minimize spotting. Avoid any sudden temperature changes in the wash waters.
4. Drape the film carefully on a wash line to air dry. Try to keep the drying area dust free and avoid any surface contact to the wet emulsion side of the film. When the film is dry, clean and lubricate it by hand with a suitable film cleaner, as you wind it onto a reel. The ideal way to recondition water damaged film would be to have it go through a normal motion picture processing machine while using the proper solutions for the particular damaged films. One of the companies that restores or rejuvenates films may be able to help you.
Note: The chemicals in this solution may be restricted and in some areas considered toxic.
Remove each roll of safety film from its container and examine it carefully on the outside and at the film end. Please remember to note if there is a vinegar like (acetic acid) odor. If there is anything to suspect at all, you should rewind the film and thoroughly examine it. Early detection can save greater effort later and, perhaps, save the existence of a film. Frequency of inspection depends on the quality of the storage and the value of the films.
Where you stay within the safe limits of temperature and relative humidity, an inspection about every 2 years is probably sufficient. But when the climate goes beyond specified limits, increase the inspection program.
If it is truly impossible to maintain this kind of frequent and thorough inspection, you should at least sample the stored films to detect early problems that may be affecting other films. Do not fall into the comforting habit of looking only at the same films or inspecting within the same areas of the storage room. And please, if there is any sign of fungus or vinegar like odor, or other film damage, widen the search immediately, so that corrective action can be taken. Often the first indication of deterioration of acetate films is the very distinctive previously noted vinegar like (acidic acid) odor when the film container is first opened. If the situation is bad, you may need help. Be sure only those people who are familiar with good film handling techniques are involved with inspection and segregation.
Extended Storage of Processed Acetate Film
The film archivist is responsible for materials that have great historical or aesthetic value. Since film is barely a century old and has gone through continuous research and development, you are not dealing with a set of settled questions and answers. What holds for one film may be less true, or not true, for another. You must know what kinds of films you have and what characteristics of their long range life are known. Actually, you can use only black and white (silver) images on safety or polyester base for strictly extended life expectancy purposes.
One of the best ways of providing maximum protection for the longest keeping times for film, or any other medium, is to store one or more copies in different locations. No matter what precautions you take, there is always the chance of an accident. With motion picture films, storing the original, separations, master positive, duplicate negative, internegative, or print in different locations makes a great deal of sense. Storing them at different locations doesn't mean within the same building but many miles apart to protect them against fires or major natural disasters. Let's look at ways of providing the best possible protection before discussing reasonable compromises.
Specifications for Extended Storage
2. Store the film on a moisture proof core in a suitable corrosion resistant can stacked horizontally on a shelf. Do not seal the can.
3. Locate and construct the storage space as a 6 hour fire resistive vault according to state and local building codes; the Fire Underwriters' regulations (U.S.A) permit an approved air conditioning installation (more on this later).
4. Protect the film from water damage of any type.
5. Provide sufficient insulation with a suitable vapor seal to permit satisfactory temperature control during all seasons of the year and to prevent moisture condensation on, or within, the walls
6. Condition and control the air automatically at 20 to 30 percent RH and not over 21°C (70°F). Take necessary precautions to prevent moisture condensation on film after removing it from the vault. For color films, colder storage temperatures are strongly recommended and additional recommendations may be available from the film manufacturer or from ANSI.
Preparation for Storage
Do not expend energy on valuable film that is not clean and repaired. When you're ready to store the film, wind it on a suitable rustproof core and place it in the best metal can available, replacing the old can with a new one as needed. Be sure that the lid is loose fitting to let in conditioned air while keeping out dust. If you must use film in an area where the relative humidity is below 15 percent or above 60 percent, allow it to be reconditioned to the storage area's relative humidity before resuming it to the can.
The vault should be located on either the ground floor or upper floors in a fireproof building, provided that the supporting and overhead floors are of sufficient strength. A basement is often damp and sometimes can become flooded.
The National Fire Protection Association advises against air conditioning in valuable (paper) record rooms because of possible fire hazard from the outside coming through the duct work. If the climate is a problem, there probably is no choice. Proper air conditioning is almost always essential for long term preservation of extended life expectancy storage of films. The fire hazard introduced by the openings in the room for air conditioning ducts may be overcome by the use of Underwriters' approved automatic fire control dampers in ducts, installed in accordance with recommendations of the National Fire Protection Association.
An automatic sprinkler system inside a fire resistive vault containing only safety films is not necessary. Its elimination decreases the danger of accidental water damage to the films. if a sprinkler system is not installed, keep out all combustible furnishings and materials other that the safety films and the metal containers. In this connection, consult local building codes plus the Fire Underwriters' and National Fire Protection Association's regulations concerning valuable record rooms. If you use automatic carbon dioxide fire extinguishing equipment in the film vault, you must have a warning device to permit anyone in the room to escape before the carbon dioxide is released.
To avoid breakdowns and costly repairs, be sure to consider equipment constructed of corrosion resistant, high quality materials. Ideally, the conditioner should be located outside the vault for ease of maintenance and to prevent leakage of water in the vault in case of a breakdown. The conditioner housing and all duct work should be well insulated. The control of room conditions calls for appropriate instruments, such as a dry or wet bulb thermostat, hydrostat, or dew point controller.
Economizing to some extent (never recommended) may be done because of the leeway in temperature relative humidity requirements for the life expectancy of the films. It is possible to pass air through a cooling coil to freeze out excess moisture and then reheat the air instead of using a spray chamber. This technique prevents high humidity the greatest danger to film but doesn't prevent low humidity in dry seasons. Although this doesn't meet the requirements of the ANSI or ISO Standards, it allows the use of a lower capacity cooling system. You should check temperature and relative humidity daily with the proper equipment or use a continuous automatic monitoring system.
Clean the vault frequently to prevent the accumulation of lint from clothing and dirt from shoes, etc. if a spray chamber is used in the air conditioner, and the water is recirculated, clean the chamber too. This will prevent the formation of biological slime that can eventually decompose and give off hydrogen sulfide, one of film's chemical enemies. Air purification units also require occasional servicing. Take safeguards when equipment is turned off for maintenance or out of order.
If there is atmospheric contamination in your locality, consult an environmental engineer to help you select the best type of air scrubber, activated charcoal absorber, or other air purification equipment for the situation. You may benefit from an installation like that at the Harvard Rare Book Library with its Gutenberg Bible and other treasures.
Special Considerations for Color Films on Safety Base
One possibility is to make panchromatic black and white copies of valuable color films onto polyester base films for extended life preservation. This is sometimes done, but one could feel that it violates the first principles of the archivist, namely, to preserve the record in its original form, which in this case means color. Another possibility is to make three black and white separation negatives from the color print. You could use them to make a new color print through a color intermediate system at any future time. This is an expensive procedure but probably justified.
Factors that contribute to fading of color films are heat, moisture, and light. Projection of motion picture film is so rapid and the form of storage is such that light is not much of a problem. For optimum preservation of the dyes in color film, store the film in a cold, dry environment for maximum permanence. The storage temperature should be 2°C (36°F) or lower with relative humidity at about 20 to 30 percent.
Laboratory tests show that the dyes in color films keep even better if the RH is lower than 20 percent. However, the lower the moisture content of the film, the more problems you'll encounter from brittleness, curl, spokiness, and other film distortions. From a strictly physical standpoint, a relative humidity of 20 to 30 percent is considered best. It's important to arrive at a reasonable compromise for your purposes and conditions.
Accurate control of the moisture content of films requires some analytical facilities and technical supervision. Never desiccate any collection of color films of appreciable size and value, to be preserved indefinitely, without such facilities.